A business that paid for advice and lost money has to decide whether to absorb the loss or pursue the adviser who gave it. Clients bring professional negligence claims when they say the service they paid for fell short of the standard the law requires of the adviser and caused them financial loss. The decision to bring one is commercial as much as it is legal, because it turns on the documents available, the size of the recoverable loss and the cost of pursuing it. The matters that settle that decision are the terms of the engagement, the party that holds the claim, the loss itself and the time limits that apply.
What professional negligence claims involve
A professional negligence claim is a claim by a client against a professional adviser, alleging that the service provided fell below the standard the law requires and caused financial loss. Claims commonly concern advice or work by an accountant, a valuer, an engineer, a broker or a building surveyor. Whether a claim is available on particular facts is a question for advice.
The engagement is where the examination starts. A contract may be formed partly through oral discussions, partly in writing and partly by the parties’ conduct, so the retainer letter, the scope of work, the fee proposal and the surrounding correspondence all bear on what the adviser agreed to do. A disappointing commercial result is where the inquiry begins. It does not finish it.
Which party holds the claim
Where a company entered into the contract, the contractual rights and obligations will ordinarily belong to the company rather than personally to its directors or shareholders. Identifying the contracting parties is therefore an important first step.
In a closely held business this has practical consequences. The entity that holds the claim is the entity that must prove the loss, fund the proceeding and carry the risk of an adverse costs order. Where the advice concerned a transaction, a trust or a shareholding, the engagement may have been with one entity while the loss sits in another, and that distinction shapes the claim.
The documents that decide the claim
Most of the early work is documentary. The engagement letter, the scope of work, the written instructions and the advice itself will decide more of the claim than anyone’s recollection of a meeting. Contemporaneous records carry weight, so the file notes, emails and board papers from the time matter.
The questions a director should be able to answer from those documents are these:
- What the adviser was engaged to do, and what the engagement expressly excluded.
- What information the adviser was given, and what was withheld or arrived late.
- Whether the advice was qualified, caveated or made conditional on something that was never provided.
- What the business would have done differently had the advice been different.
- Whether any other adviser or party contributed to the same loss.
- What the engagement documents say about liability.
The fourth question usually requires the most evidence, because the answer must rest on the records of the decision at the time. Board papers, approvals and internal correspondence from that period carry more weight than a later account of what the business would have done.
What compensation professional negligence claims may cover
Compensation in a claim of this kind reflects the financial loss the client says it suffered because of the service. Before a figure is put to an adviser or an insurer, the business should be able to state it precisely and support each part of it.
Quantifying the loss usually begins with the amount paid for the service and the expenditure committed on the strength of it. The cost of correcting the problem may follow, along with any loss flowing from the transaction the advice concerned, such as the difference between the price paid and the value received. Each figure needs a document behind it.
How much of that total is recoverable is a separate question, and it depends on the legal basis of the claim and the terms of the engagement. Many retainers contain terms addressing liability, and where more than one adviser was involved the position can become more complicated. For that reason, an early and realistic view of the recoverable figure is more useful than a headline number.
Time limits and the step that comes before court
A contractual claim is commonly subject to a six-year limitation period running from the date of breach, but different periods and exceptions may apply. Section 5(1)(a) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1958 (Vic) provides the period for an action on a simple contract, and for an ordinary breach time runs from when the breach occurs, even if the loss is discovered later. Because a claim against an adviser may be framed in more than one way, the applicable period should be confirmed on the facts as soon as the problem comes to light.
What happens before a proceeding starts
Court proceedings are not ordinarily the first step in resolving a commercial dispute. A letter of demand setting out the relevant contractual term, the alleged breach, the resulting loss and the remedy sought will generally be sent first. This approach is consistent with the overarching obligations under the Civil Procedure Act 2010 (Vic). Those obligations include using reasonable endeavours to resolve the dispute by agreement (s 22) and, if it cannot be resolved, narrowing the issues in dispute (s 23). The Act does not make a letter of demand compulsory in every case, particularly where urgent interlocutory relief is required.
Before proceedings are commenced, the parties may exchange information, engage in without-prejudice negotiations or attend mediation. Care should be taken to distinguish open correspondence, which may later be relied upon in Court, from without-prejudice communications directed to settlement. Where the loss arose out of a transaction or a continuing commercial relationship, the claim against the adviser and the underlying property or business dispute are best considered together.
Frequently asked questions about professional negligence claims
Yes. The claim depends on the terms of the engagement, what the accountant was asked to do and the loss that followed, and the evidence must establish each of those.
Six years is the common position for a contractual claim, running from the date of breach, but different periods and exceptions may apply. Because time can run from an event well before the problem became apparent, the limitation position should be checked as soon as the issue is identified.
No. A disappointing result may have several causes, so the inquiry examines what the adviser agreed to do and what the adviser did.
A clear view of the loss before the cost
The practical starting point is the engagement file and the records of the decisions taken after the advice was given. With the retainer, the instructions, the advice and the loss documented, the claim can be assessed properly: what the adviser agreed to do, what the records show, what figure is realistically recoverable and whether it justifies the cost and management time of pursuing it. Legal costs depend on the nature, complexity and scope of the matter. We explain the applicable fee arrangements and provide costs information in accordance with our legal obligations before commencing substantive work.
Mazzeo Lawyers is a Melbourne litigation practice acting for clients throughout Victoria in property and business disputes, with more than three decades of practice behind it. The firm acts in matters before the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal, the County Court of Victoria, the Supreme Court of Victoria, the Federal Court of Australia, and the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The Principal is Nick Mazzeo, and both Nick Mazzeo and Mazzeo Lawyers are members of the Law Institute of Victoria. Every matter the firm acts in receives the time and personal attention of an experienced lawyer.
All enquiries are handled in strict confidence, and an initial conversation does not commit you to anything. Arrange a confidential discussion about your matter.


